The Dark Knight. Your Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man. Two iconic heroes from different universes who, on the surface, seem extremely different. Yet these two have risen above nearly all other superheroes in popularity throughout the years. There have been many different interpretations of them across various mediums, each of which receive praise for various aspects of their stories and characterizations. Even with the advent of the MCU raising the popularity of characters like Tony Stark, Steve Rogers, and Natasha Romanoff, these two still reign supreme as the most widely popular heroes of them all. Today, we’ll explore what makes them so beloved and how Batman and Spider-Man may be more similar than one might think. With that said, let’s get started!
For starters, let’s focus on the differences between the two characters. Most obvious is superpowers, or lack thereof. Batman is perhaps the most famous superhero in the world, and his fame is largely due to his lack of any superhuman abilities. Bruce Wayne always describes Batman in relation to the rest of the Justice League as “just a man.” But Batman’s lack of powers is not widely known to his enemies, particularly the criminal underworld of Gotham. Using his incredible skills with stealth and intimidation, Wayne has made Batman into a creature of mythological proportions. Criminals of all types fear and respect him and his turf, sometimes to the point that they will avoid any operations in Gotham city in favor of Metropolis or Blüdhaven, even knowing that those cities are protected by Superman and Nightwing, respectively. Batman’s mere existence scares criminals off, powers or no powers.
Spider-Man, on the other hand, is an extremely powerful and versatile fighter thanks to his superhuman abilities. First, Peter Parker has enhanced strength on par with, or sometimes exceeding, that of super-soldiers like Steve Rogers. Along with this is his incredible spider-like agility and ability to climb walls and ceilings, making his fighting style quite unpredictable. But best of all is his sixth sense, or the Spider-Sense, which renders sneak attacks and illusions ineffective against him. To a lesser degree, Spider-Man has also demonstrated enhanced durability and a healing factor. While nothing compared to Logan’s healing abilities, Spider-Man has still proven time and again that he’s more than capable of taking a beating. Overall, Spider-Man’s powers, while not as flashy as those of Thor or Doctor Strange, are among the best for any superhero to have.
Another key difference between the characters is their character and typical style of storytelling. Batman, for example, is dark and brooding with adventures featuring realistic violence, mob bosses, and corrupt politicians. There were times that he was made more family-friendly, particularly in the Silver Age, but darkness has been a consistent character trait for Batman over the years. The modern Batman never jokes around, usually remaining silent while engaged in combat with one of his rogues despite their efforts to get a rise out of him. Deep down, Bruce doesn’t trust himself to enjoy any part of his actions, fearing how far he might go if he did enjoy it.
Spider-Man, on the other hand, is bright and friendly, always stopping to chat with his fellow New Yorkers and throwing out quips and puns while he takes down criminals in his city. Moreover, his web-shooters basically turn New York City into his personal playground – Spidey is so associated with the Big Apple because the city was almost designed for him and his powers! This is one of the biggest reasons that Spider-Man is the most popular superhero for younger children. Not only is he a nice guy, but he’s just plain fun. I don’t know if there’s a single superhero in any medium who enjoys superheroing more than Spider-Man.
The final key difference between these two characters is their alter egos. Bruce Wayne is a mega-wealthy billionaire with unlimited financial resources, which he uses for his war on crime. Wayne has trained all over the world in different martial arts, become a master escape artist, studied every known investigative method, and trains with his advanced weaponry on a daily basis. Some might go so far as to say that money is Bruce Wayne’s superpower. While I disagree, it’s a fair point to consider.
Peter Parker, on the other hand, is a poor high school student, later a photographer, who struggles to pay his rent. Poverty is one of his defining characteristics. While he does develop advanced weapons and equipment to use as Spider-Man, he often does so with “guerilla science,” as we see with his initial introduction in the MCU and in the 2018 video game, Spider-Man. His teachers and mentors always marvel at his ability to craft things from seemingly useless spare parts, yet always call him lazy and absentminded, unaware of his stressful double life.
As we have seen, Bruce Wayne and Peter Parker appear to live at opposite ends of the financial and socioeconomic ladder, probably leading some of you to wonder why I’m putting them in the same league with each other. Here is where we begin to see how similar they really are.
One must look no further than the origin of each character’s crusade for justice to find their first similarity – tragedy. Both Bruce Wayne and Peter Parker had their lives drastically altered by tragic deaths, namely Bruce’s parents and Peter’s uncle. Each learned different lessons from said tragedy – Bruce learning that criminals are superstitious, cowardly, and in need of something to fear, while Peter learning about great power and great responsibility – but this parallel cannot be ignored. Moreover, tragedy continues to be a factor in their lives as they come into their own. Each loses someone dear to them in the course of their heroism, Jason Todd for Batman and Gwen Stacy for Spider-Man. This loss becomes a defining moment for each of them, haunting them for years to come and establishing the killer of each as their arch-nemesis. This is a harsh world, and so many from all different walks of life can identify with the tragic stories of these two heroes.
Another striking similarity between these two is their rogues’ gallery, each of which is considered the best group of villains in their respective comic book universes. As heroes, Batman and Spider-Man have amazing empathy for understanding that most of their enemies are insane, rather than evil. Yet their greatest enemies, Joker and Green Goblin, are so insane that they blur the line between the two. They also devote much of their time to bringing down the corrupt criminals in their cities who aren’t insane, such as Penguin and Falcone for Batman and Vulture and Kingpin for Spider-Man. They both want to help individuals who are clearly mentally ill, even if those individuals are their enemies, but won’t stand for outright corruption. For that matter, they’re both forced to occasionally team up with one of their enemies, such as Deadshot or Venom.
Oh, and how about their love lives? Batman tends to prefer the femme fatale archetype with Selena Kyle and Talia al Ghul, where Spidey usually goes more girl-next-door with Gwen Stacy and Mary Jane Watson, though Felicia Hardy does sometimes get her claws into Spidey. But regardless of the type of woman each goes for, they are united in their sheer inability to maintain a steady relationship with any of their love interests. This is rarely for a lack of trying, as they both do desire love and companionship, but when the stress of their double lives increases, both will choose to keep protecting people over their own happiness.
These similarities highlight the biggest reason for the enduring success and popularity of both Batman and Spider-Man. For all their differences, both heroes are street-level heroes at the core of their beings. They don’t focus on global or cosmic threats unless asked to help by the Justice League or Avengers, instead wanting to help keep their neighborhoods safe for the average Joes and Janes. In essence, they’re both blue-collar superheroes with tragic stories of loss, self-imposed loneliness, and constant sacrifice of their own desires to help others.
Even with god-like heroes the likes of Superman and Thor, people still want to believe in regular people being the best of heroes. They want to believe that one man can choose to devote his fortune to fighting crime and corruption. They want to believe in a high school student who heeds his uncle’s dying words and tries to keep his neighborhood safe. Those are the sort of heroes that will always resonate with regular people. Superman and Thor are certainly flashy and powerful, but we all want to believe Batman or Spider-Man could be living next door to us right now. Best of all, their street-level efforts often have the effect of inspiring their neighbors to act, devoting their own efforts to making their city a better place to live. That’s the mark of a true hero.
So always remember, criminals are a superstitious and cowardly lot, but with great power comes great responsibility.
I hope you enjoyed this look into two of the best heroes around. They’re certainly two of my favorite heroes ever, and I never tire of studying their tales and seeing what can be learned from them. If you did enjoy this blog entry, please let me know in the comments. Feel free to mention if you have any ideas or requests for future entries. I’ve got an active running list of ideas, but I’m always open to more. I’d appreciate it if you’d leave a like and share this post on social media. And to stay up to date on future blog posts, you can sign up for my monthly newsletter on my website. Until the next story!
Comentarios